WallStSmart

Extra Space Storage Inc (EXR)vsPennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust (PMT)

VS
⚡

Smart Verdict

WallStSmart Research — data-driven comparison

Extra Space Storage Inc generates 827% more annual revenue ($3.52B vs $379.64M). EXR leads profitability with a 29.5% profit margin vs 21.7%. PMT appears more attractively valued with a PEG of 0.76. PMT earns a higher WallStSmart Score of 66/100 (B-).

EXR

Buy

61

out of 100

Grade: C+

Growth: 7.3Profit: 8.0Value: 3.3Quality: 3.0
Piotroski: 3/9Altman Z: 0.81

PMT

Strong Buy

66

out of 100

Grade: B-

Growth: 6.3Profit: 6.0Value: 8.7Quality: 3.3
Piotroski: 3/9
IV

Intrinsic Value Comparison

Multi-model valuation · Graham Formula

EXRFair Value (-4.9%)

Margin of Safety

-4.9%

Fair Value

$135.86

Current Price

$154.91

$19.05 premium

UndervaluedFair: $135.86Overvalued
PMTUndervalued (+59.1%)

Margin of Safety

+59.1%

Fair Value

$30.21

Current Price

$7.49

$22.72 discount

UndervaluedFair: $30.21Overvalued

Key Strengths & Concerns

Side-by-side fundamental analysis

Key Strengths

EXR4 strengths · Avg: 9.3/10
Operating MarginProfitability
44.9%10/10

Strong operational efficiency at 44.9%

EPS GrowthGrowth
50.3%10/10

Earnings expanding 50.3% YoY

Profit MarginProfitability
29.5%9/10

Keeps 30 of every $100 in revenue as profit

Price/BookValuation
2.5x8/10

Reasonable price relative to book value

PMT4 strengths · Avg: 8.8/10
Price/BookValuation
0.5x10/10

Reasonable price relative to book value

Profit MarginProfitability
21.7%9/10

Keeps 22 of every $100 in revenue as profit

PEG RatioValuation
0.768/10

Growing faster than its price suggests

P/E RatioValuation
15.5x8/10

Attractively priced relative to earnings

Areas to Watch

EXR4 concerns · Avg: 3.5/10
P/E RatioValuation
32.6x4/10

Premium valuation, high expectations priced in

Revenue GrowthGrowth
1.1%4/10

1.1% revenue growth

Debt/EquityHealth
1.103/10

Elevated debt levels

Piotroski F-ScoreQuality
3/93/10

Weak financial health signals

PMT4 concerns · Avg: 2.8/10
Market CapQuality
$717.67M3/10

Smaller company, higher risk/reward

Return on EquityProfitability
4.7%3/10

ROE of 4.7% — below average capital efficiency

Piotroski F-ScoreQuality
3/93/10

Weak financial health signals

Free Cash FlowQuality
$-2.75B2/10

Negative free cash flow — burning cash

Comparative Analysis Report

WallStSmart Research

Bull Case : EXR

The strongest argument for EXR centers on Operating Margin, EPS Growth, Profit Margin. Profitability is solid with margins at 29.5% and operating margin at 44.9%.

Bull Case : PMT

The strongest argument for PMT centers on Price/Book, Profit Margin, PEG Ratio. Profitability is solid with margins at 21.7% and operating margin at 16.7%. PEG of 0.76 suggests the stock is reasonably priced for its growth.

Bear Case : EXR

The primary concerns for EXR are P/E Ratio, Revenue Growth, Debt/Equity.

Bear Case : PMT

The primary concerns for PMT are Market Cap, Return on Equity, Piotroski F-Score. Debt-to-equity of 13.86 is elevated, increasing financial risk.

Key Dynamics to Monitor

EXR profiles as a value stock while PMT is a mature play — different risk/reward profiles.

PMT carries more volatility with a beta of 1.18 — expect wider price swings.

PMT is growing revenue faster at 6.1% — sustainability is the question.

EXR generates stronger free cash flow (426M), providing more financial flexibility.

Bottom Line

PMT scores higher overall (66/100 vs 61/100), backed by strong 21.7% margins. Both earn "Strong Buy" and "Buy" ratings respectively — the choice depends on your investment horizon and risk tolerance.

This analysis is generated from publicly available financial data. Not financial advice.

Extra Space Storage Inc

REAL ESTATE · REIT - INDUSTRIAL · USA

Extra Space Storage is a real estate investment trust headquartered in Cottonwood Heights, Utah that invests in self storage units.

Visit Website →

PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust

REAL ESTATE · REIT - MORTGAGE · USA

PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust, a specialty finance company, invests primarily in mortgage-related assets in the United States. The company is headquartered in Westlake Village, California.

Visit Website →

Want to dig deeper into these stocks?