WallStSmart
AFGE

American Financial Group, Inc.

NYSE: AFGE · FINANCIALS · INSURANCE

$16.98
-0.31% today

Updated 2026-06-05

Market cap
$9.87B
P/E ratio
P/S ratio
EPS (TTM)
$—
Dividend yield
6.71%
52W range
$15 – $18
Volume
0.0M

WallStSmart proprietary scores

20
out of 100
Grade: F
Strong Sell
Investment rating
4.7
Growth
C
4.0
Quality
C
5.0
Profitability
C+
5.0
Valuation
C+
3/9
Piotroski F-Score
Weak
0.2
Altman Z-Score
Distress
Industry rank
View all highly rated stocks (75+) →202 stocks currently score above 75

Price targets

Analyst target
12-Month target
Intrinsic (DCF)
Margin of safety

Price chart

Stock snapshot

Strengths
+ Free cash flow $457.00M — positive
+ Debt/equity 0.39x — low leverage
Risks
- Piotroski 3/9 — weak financial health
- Altman Z 0.17 — distress zone
- Thin margins at 0.00%

Key financials

Revenue Net Income Free Cash Flow
Metric2022202320242025TTM
Revenue$6.77B$7.73B$8.28B$8.17B$1.85B
Net income$898.00M$852.00M$887.00M$842.00M$191.00M
EPS$—
Free cash flow$1.07B$1.90B$1.02B$1.40B$457.00M
Profit margin13.26%11.02%10.72%10.30%

Recent insider activity

DateInsiderTypeSharesPrice
2026-02-27HERTZMAN, BRIAN S.Sale1,663$133.70
2026-02-26WEISS, MARK ABuy3,012
2026-02-26THOMPSON, DAVID LAWRENCE JRBuy4,706

Peer comparison

CompanyMkt CapScoreGrowthProfitValueQualityMoSRating
AFGE$9.87B204.75.05.04.0Avoid
MGR$5.15B283.35.55.05.3Avoid
HCXY$1.31B185.35.05.37.5Avoid
MHLA$1.03B183.33.55.04.0Avoid
ECCX$454.62M184.34.06.05.0Avoid
CLBR$366.35M376.33.54.07.0Hold

Smart narrative

American Financial Group, Inc. trades at $16.98. Our Smart Value Score of 20/100 indicates the stock is weak. The company scores 3/9 on the Piotroski F-Score. With an Altman Z-Score of 0.17, it sits in the distress.

Frequently asked questions

What is American Financial Group, Inc.'s stock price?

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFGE) trades at $16.98.

Is American Financial Group, Inc. overvalued?

American Financial Group, Inc. carries a Smart Value Score of 20/100 (Grade F), which we rate Strong Sell. That score blends growth, quality, and valuation into one read.

Altman Z-Score?

American Financial Group, Inc.'s Altman Z-Score is 0.17, which places it in the distress. The Altman Z-Score gauges bankruptcy risk from profitability, leverage, and asset efficiency, and a higher reading points to lower financial distress risk.

Company info

SectorFINANCIALS
IndustryINSURANCE
CountryUSA
ExchangeNYSE
CurrencyUSD

Quick metrics

P/S ratio
ROE18.79%
Beta
50D MA$16.62
200D MA$17.41
Shares out
Float
Short ratio
Avg volume0.0M

Performance

1 week-1.62%
1 month-4.14%
3 months-3.01%
YTD-2.84%
1 year
3 years
5 years