WallStSmart

Caterpillar Inc (CAT)vsGreenbrier Companies Inc (GBX)

VS
⚡

Smart Verdict

WallStSmart Research — data-driven comparison

Caterpillar Inc generates 3060% more annual revenue ($77.77B vs $2.46B). CAT leads profitability with a 15.2% profit margin vs 3.2%. GBX appears more attractively valued with a PEG of 0.58. CAT earns a higher WallStSmart Score of 73/100 (B).

CAT

Strong Buy

73

out of 100

Grade: B

Growth: 7.3Profit: 8.5Value: 5.7Quality: 4.5
Piotroski: 3/9Altman Z: 2.40

GBX

Buy

50

out of 100

Grade: C-

Growth: 2.0Profit: 4.5Value: 6.0Quality: 6.0
Piotroski: 4/9Altman Z: 1.77
IV

Intrinsic Value Comparison

Multi-model valuation · Graham Formula

Intrinsic value data unavailable for CAT.

GBXSignificantly Overvalued (-46.1%)

Margin of Safety

-46.1%

Fair Value

$37.67

Current Price

$40.30

$2.63 premium

UndervaluedFair: $37.67Overvalued

Key Strengths & Concerns

Side-by-side fundamental analysis

Key Strengths

CAT5 strengths · Avg: 8.8/10
Market CapQuality
$276.97B10/10

Mega-cap, among the largest globally

Return on EquityProfitability
55.1%10/10

Every $100 of equity generates 55 in profit

Revenue GrowthGrowth
17.3%8/10

17.3% revenue growth

EPS GrowthGrowth
46.1%8/10

Earnings expanding 46.1% YoY

Free Cash FlowQuality
$3.40B8/10

Generating 3.4B in free cash flow

GBX3 strengths · Avg: 8.7/10
Price/BookValuation
0.8x10/10

Reasonable price relative to book value

PEG RatioValuation
0.588/10

Growing faster than its price suggests

P/E RatioValuation
17.1x8/10

Attractively priced relative to earnings

Areas to Watch

CAT3 concerns · Avg: 2.7/10
Price/BookValuation
12.1x4/10

Trading at 12.1x book value

Piotroski F-ScoreQuality
3/93/10

Weak financial health signals

Debt/EquityHealth
2.101/10

Elevated debt levels

GBX4 concerns · Avg: 3.3/10
Altman Z-ScoreHealth
1.774/10

Distress zone — elevated risk

Market CapQuality
$1.32B3/10

Smaller company, higher risk/reward

Profit MarginProfitability
3.2%3/10

3.2% margin — thin

Operating MarginProfitability
4.3%3/10

Operating margin of 4.3%

Comparative Analysis Report

WallStSmart Research

Bull Case : CAT

The strongest argument for CAT centers on Market Cap, Return on Equity, Revenue Growth. Profitability is solid with margins at 15.2% and operating margin at 18.8%. Revenue growth of 17.3% demonstrates continued momentum.

Bull Case : GBX

The strongest argument for GBX centers on Price/Book, PEG Ratio, P/E Ratio. PEG of 0.58 suggests the stock is reasonably priced for its growth.

Bear Case : CAT

The primary concerns for CAT are Price/Book, Piotroski F-Score, Debt/Equity. Debt-to-equity of 2.10 is elevated, increasing financial risk.

Bear Case : GBX

The primary concerns for GBX are Altman Z-Score, Market Cap, Profit Margin. Thin 3.2% margins leave little buffer for downturns.

Key Dynamics to Monitor

CAT profiles as a growth stock while GBX is a value play — different risk/reward profiles.

CAT carries more volatility with a beta of 1.64 — expect wider price swings.

CAT is growing revenue faster at 17.3% — sustainability is the question.

CAT generates stronger free cash flow (3.4B), providing more financial flexibility.

Bottom Line

CAT scores higher overall (73/100 vs 50/100), backed by strong 15.2% margins and 17.3% revenue growth. Both earn "Strong Buy" and "Buy" ratings respectively — the choice depends on your investment horizon and risk tolerance.

This analysis is generated from publicly available financial data. Not financial advice.

Caterpillar Inc

INDUSTRIALS · FARM & HEAVY CONSTRUCTION MACHINERY · USA

Caterpillar Inc. (often shortened to CAT) is an American Fortune 100 corporation that designs, develops, engineers, manufactures, markets, and sells machinery, engines, financial products, and insurance to customers via a worldwide dealer network.

Visit Website →

Greenbrier Companies Inc

INDUSTRIALS · RAILROADS · USA

The Greenbrier Companies, Inc. designs, manufactures and markets rail freight car equipment in North America, Europe and South America. The company is headquartered in Lake Oswego, Oregon.

Want to dig deeper into these stocks?